10 Tough Lessons on Grading and Preserving Ancient Roman Coins I Learned the Hard Way

I’ll never forget the first time I held an authentic Roman coin. It wasn’t a shiny, museum-quality piece. It was a humble little bronze coin, maybe a follis from the time of Constantine, dark and a little rough, but with an almost electric sense of history in my palm. The tiny, worn-down face of the emperor still peered out, a ghost from nearly two millennia ago. It was a rush, and it was the start of an obsession. But let me tell you, that rush can turn into a headache faster than you can say “Vespasian” if you don't know what you're doing. I’ve made every mistake in the book—from "cleaning" a coin into a worthless disc of metal to buying a slabbed grade that was, shall we say, a bit generous. This guide is for every one of you who wants to dive into this incredible hobby without losing your mind or your money. It’s about the real-world, no-nonsense lessons that the glossy catalogs and academic papers don't always teach you.

An Introduction to Ancient Roman Coins: More Than Just Metal

When you start collecting, the sheer variety of ancient Roman coins is overwhelming. There's the early Roman Republic's silver denarii, the copper sestertii of the Empire, the bronze folles of the late Empire, and a hundred other denominations, metals, and emperors in between. Each one tells a story—of triumphs and tragedies, of political propaganda and economic collapse. The portraits on them aren't just art; they're the Instagram feeds of their day, a way for an emperor to project power and legitimacy across an empire. The reverses, with their depictions of gods, virtues, or military scenes, are just as crucial. Understanding these stories is the first step, and it's what separates a true numismatist from someone who just buys pretty objects.

You’ll quickly learn that unlike modern coins with their perfect strikes and unblemished surfaces, ancient coins are, by their very nature, imperfect. They were hammered by hand, not stamped by a machine. This means no two are exactly alike. They’ve been buried, discovered, and handled by countless people over centuries. They carry the marks of their journey, and those marks are part of their history. The challenge—and the joy—is in learning to see past the grime and wear to the history beneath.

I remember purchasing a beautiful silver denarius, and I was so excited to get it home. I put it in a flip, tucked it away, and didn't really look at it again for a few weeks. When I did, I noticed a tiny, almost invisible green spot forming on the edge. I panicked. What was it? Was it "bronze disease"? Was my coin going to disintegrate? It turned out to be nothing serious, just a minor bit of verdigris from a previous, poor cleaning, but it was my first real-world lesson that these are not just objects; they are chemical reactors that require a delicate hand and a lot of patience.

The Complex Art of Grading Ancient Roman Coins

This is where things get tricky. Unlike modern coins graded on the predictable Sheldon scale from 1 to 70, ancient coins have a more… fluid system. A modern coin’s grade is all about preservation and wear. An ancient coin’s grade is a holistic judgment call. It’s about more than just the amount of wear; it’s about the quality of the strike, the style of the dies, the condition of the surface, and the eye appeal. This is why you’ll often see terms like “Very Fine (VF),” “Fine (F),” or “Good (G)” used, but they are often accompanied by a description of the coin’s individual quirks.

A coin can be heavily worn but still considered "Fine" if the strike was particularly strong and the portrait retains character. Conversely, a coin with minimal wear might only be "Very Fine" if it has a weak strike or a porous surface. Professionals at grading services like NGC Ancients use their own internal scales, which often include a separate numerical rating for strike and surface, which I've found to be a game-changer. They understand that a Roman coin from a well-made die is fundamentally different from a hastily made one, even if they have the same amount of wear.

So, what are the key factors in grading ancient Roman coins? I break it down into the "Three S's" plus one more crucial factor:

• Strike: How well was the design impressed onto the coin blank? Were the dies centered? Was the strike strong enough to bring out all the details, or are some parts mushy? A coin with a bold, well-centered strike is a thing of beauty, regardless of wear.
• Surface: This is huge. Is the surface smooth and well-preserved, or is it porous, pitted, or covered in a thick, lumpy patina? A coin's surface tells its life story—it can show signs of corrosion, ancient cleaning, or damage from being buried for centuries.
• Style: This is the artistic quality of the die itself. Some celators (engravers) were true artists, creating portraits of incredible realism and expression. Others… were not. A coin struck from a "Fine Style" die is often more valuable and desirable than a similar coin from a cruder die.
• Eye Appeal: This is the subjective part, but it's arguably the most important for your personal collection. Does the coin "pop"? Is the patina attractive and uniform? Does the coin just feel right in your hand? If it makes you happy to look at it, that’s its true value to you, regardless of what a professional grade might say.

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them: My Biggest Blunders

I wish I could say I was a natural at this, but I wasn't. My early days were a minefield of bad decisions. Here are the big ones I fell for, so you don't have to.

Mistake #1: The "Cleaning" Catastrophe. Oh, I was so excited to make my first purchase shine! I read some forum posts and decided to try a "light" cleaning with a household product. What I ended up with was a bright, shiny, and utterly destroyed coin. The patina—that beautiful, centuries-old layer of oxidation—was gone, replaced by a raw, unnatural look that instantly tanked its value. The cardinal rule: If you don't know exactly what you're doing, do nothing! A coin with a nice, stable patina is almost always more valuable and beautiful than a cleaned one.

Mistake #2: Believing the Grade is Everything. While grading services are a fantastic tool, they are not the be-all and end-all, especially with ancient coins. I once bought a coin that was graded as a "Fine" but had an incredible, rich green patina and a powerful, almost haunting portrait. On the other hand, I've seen coins graded as "VF" that were weak-struck, porous, and just... dull. Always, always, always look at the coin itself. Use high-resolution photos, or better yet, see it in person. The grade is a guide, not a gospel.

Mistake #3: Ignoring Provenance. Where did the coin come from? Was it an old collection, or a recent find from an archaeological site? A coin from a known, respected collection with a long history is almost always safer and more desirable than a random find. Provenance adds trust and a story to the object, and as you get more serious, you'll find it matters immensely.

Mistake #4: The Lure of the "Perfect" Coin. I used to get so fixated on finding a coin with no wear, no marks, no history. But that's not what ancient coins are about. The nicks and dings tell the story of a coin that was used, that changed hands, that was part of the economy of the Roman Empire. Don't chase an unattainable ideal; instead, learn to appreciate the "battle scars" that make each coin unique.

The Golden Rules of Ancient Coin Preservation

You’ve found your perfect coin, and it’s now in your possession. Congratulations! Now the real work begins. Preservation isn't about making a coin look brand new; it's about stopping its natural decay and protecting it for the next generation. This is about being a steward, not just a collector.

Rule #1: Handle with Care. Always, always, always hold the coin by its edges. Your fingers contain oils and acids that can damage the surface and tarnish the patina over time. It’s a habit you need to ingrain from day one. I even keep a pair of soft, non-abrasive cotton gloves nearby for when I’m photographing or examining a new piece.

Rule #2: Say No to PVC. This is a huge one. Many older coin albums and flips are made of PVC (polyvinyl chloride). Over time, this material breaks down, releasing chemicals that can cause a sticky, green slime to form on your coins—a condition known as "PVC damage" or "bronze disease." It’s a disaster waiting to happen. Always use archival-safe, PVC-free holders made of materials like Mylar or inert plastics. It's a small investment that will save you a world of hurt.

Rule #3: Control the Environment. Your coins hate humidity and extreme temperature swings. A basement or a garage is a terrible place to store your collection. The ideal environment is a climate-controlled space with low, stable humidity (ideally below 50%). Investing in a small dehumidifier for your collection room or safe is a brilliant idea. Humidity is the number one enemy of bronze coins, as it can reactivate corrosion and lead to "bronze disease."

Rule #4: Individual Storage is King. Never store coins loose in a bag or box where they can rub against each other. Each coin should have its own home—a Mylar flip, a hard plastic slab, or a dedicated slot in a storage tray. This prevents contact marks and scratches, which are a major demerit in grading.

Essential Tools for a Serious Collector

You don’t need a fancy laboratory, but a few key tools will make your life a hundred times easier and safer.

• A High-Quality Magnifying Loupe: I recommend a loupe with at least 10x magnification. This is your best friend for examining details, checking for damage, and verifying a coin's authenticity. It's how you'll see a weak strike, a hairline scratch, or the delicate details of an empress's hairstyle.
• A Digital Microscope: For documenting and sharing your coins, a USB or handheld digital microscope is a game-changer. It allows you to take incredible close-up photos of your coins, which is essential for cataloging and for showing off your collection to fellow enthusiasts.
• Archival-Safe Storage: As mentioned, invest in good quality Mylar flips, hard plastic coin capsules, or purpose-built coin trays. These are the unsung heroes of your collection.
• Soft, Non-Abrasive Gloves: The cotton gloves I mentioned earlier are a simple, cheap way to protect your coins from your own skin oils. It's an easy habit to get into.

A Tale of Two Coins: A Case Study in Grading

I once had two coins that taught me a valuable lesson. The first was a sestertius of Trajan, a big, beautiful bronze coin. It was labeled as "Fine" by the dealer. It was worn, sure, and some of the lettering on the reverse was a little soft. But the portrait was bold and centered, the patina was a lovely, natural-looking dark green, and it felt like a chunk of history. It was a coin with a good story. I loved it, and it was a great price for what it was. The second coin was a silver denarius of Commodus. The dealer had it listed as "Very Fine." The surface was sharp, with very little wear, but the strike was incredibly weak, and the coin had been aggressively cleaned at some point, leaving it with a sterile, almost white appearance. It had no soul. It looked like a forgery, even though it was genuine. It felt wrong. I ended up selling it and keeping the Trajan sestertius, because I learned that a coin that feels right in your hand is worth more than a number on a label.

The lesson? Trust your own eye and your own gut. Learn the nuances of strike and surface. The value of a coin is not just in its grade, but in its story, its aesthetic, and the way it speaks to you. A well-preserved coin with a compelling story will always be a better long-term hold than a sterile, over-graded one.

A Quick Coffee Break (Ad)

Visual Snapshot — How Ancient Coin Grades Differ

As the visual guide shows, modern coin grading is a relatively simple, linear process based almost entirely on the amount of wear a coin has suffered. An ancient coin, however, is a different beast entirely. Its grade is a complex, holistic evaluation based on four key factors. The condition of the coin's surface (its patina, or lack thereof), the quality of the strike (how well it was minted), and the artistic merit of the die's style all play a massive role alongside the traditional measure of wear. This is why a coin that looks "worn" can still be highly valuable if it has a great patina and a fine style portrait, while a less worn but heavily cleaned or poorly struck coin might be considered less desirable. It's a system that rewards the nuances of history and art, not just a perfect, sterile state of preservation.

The Ultimate Ancient Coin Collector's Checklist

Before you make a purchase, run through this checklist. It’s what I use now to save myself from bad buys and future headaches.

• Is the coin from a reputable dealer or auction house? This is your first and most important line of defense. A dealer with a long history and good reputation is worth their weight in gold.
• Does the coin have a good, stable patina? Look for a uniform color and texture. Avoid coins that look unnaturally shiny, have green powdery spots, or feel sticky.
• Is the strike strong and centered? Look closely at the portrait and the legend. Can you read the letters? Is the emperor’s face clear and detailed?
• What is the condition of the surface? Look for pitting, porosity, or hairline scratches from aggressive cleaning. A smooth surface is always a plus.
• Does the coin have provenance? Is it from a well-known collection? This adds a layer of trust and history.
• Are the photos high-quality and clear? You can't evaluate a coin from a blurry thumbnail. Make sure you can see all the details.
• And most importantly: Do you love it? If the coin doesn't speak to you, it's not the right coin for your collection, no matter what its grade is.

Advanced Insights: Beyond the Basics

Once you’ve got the basics down, you can start to appreciate the more subtle details of ancient coinage. This is where the real fun begins.

Die Studies and Hoard Finds: Serious collectors often delve into die studies, which involve identifying coins struck from the same obverse or reverse die. This can reveal patterns of production and helps establish the authenticity of a coin. Similarly, learning about major hoard finds (like the Cunetio hoard or the Frome hoard in Britain) can give you context about the circulation of coins in a specific region and time period.

Countermarks and Test Cuts: Many ancient coins bear small marks that tell fascinating stories. A tiny notch on the edge might be a "test cut" to check if the coin was pure silver all the way through. A small stamp on the obverse or reverse is a "countermark," applied by a new authority or at a later date to recertify the coin for circulation. These marks, far from being damage, add to a coin's story and can increase its desirability.

Forgeries and Authentication: The world of ancient coins, like any art market, has its share of fakes. Learning to spot a modern forgery is a critical skill. I’ve learned to be wary of coins that are too perfect, too smooth, or have unnaturally uniform patina. Tools like a loupe are essential here. When in doubt, always consult a trusted expert or send the coin to a professional grading service for authentication. It's always better to be safe than sorry.

Bronze Disease: A Collector's Nightmare: This is something you must know about. Bronze disease is a highly contagious form of corrosion that can literally eat your bronze coins alive. It looks like a small, fuzzy, powdery green or light blue spot. If you see it, the coin must be isolated immediately and treated. It’s a complex chemical process, and for most collectors, getting a professional conservator involved is the safest bet. Just know what it is and what to do if you see it.

Trusted Resources

I've relied on these incredible institutions for my own learning. They're a beacon of knowledge and integrity in the numismatic world, and I highly recommend you explore them.

Explore the American Numismatic Society Discover the British Museum's Coin Collection Understand NGC Ancient Coin Grading

FAQ

Q1. What is the difference between patina and corrosion?

Patina is a stable, protective layer that forms on a coin over centuries, typically in a range of greens, browns, and blacks. Corrosion is an active, often destructive process that eats away at the coin's metal. The key difference is stability. Patina is a desirable sign of age, while corrosion is a threat to the coin's integrity.

For more on this, check out the section on The Golden Rules of Ancient Coin Preservation.

Q2. Is it safe to clean ancient Roman coins?

For most collectors, the answer is a firm no. Professional numismatists and conservators may use very specific, controlled methods, but an inexperienced collector can easily damage a coin's surface and destroy its valuable patina. A "cleaned" coin is almost always less valuable than an uncleaned one with a good patina.

Q3. How do I know if an ancient coin is real?

Authenticity is a key concern. The best way to ensure you're buying a real coin is to purchase from a reputable dealer with a strong return policy and a long track record. Learn to recognize the characteristics of a genuine coin, like natural wear, patina, and the specific style of the period. For expensive or high-risk purchases, consider sending the coin to a third-party grading service like NGC or PCGS for authentication.

Q4. What is "bronze disease" and how can I spot it?

Bronze disease is a form of active, powdery corrosion that appears as fuzzy, light green or blue spots on bronze or copper coins. It is highly contagious and can spread to other coins if not isolated. If you see it, the coin should be immediately placed in a sealed container away from your other coins and you should consult a professional conservator.

Q5. How is grading ancient coins different from modern coins?

Ancient coins are graded on a subjective, holistic scale that considers not only wear but also the quality of the strike, the condition of the surface, and the artistic style of the die. Modern coins use a linear, objective scale (the Sheldon Scale) based primarily on the coin's wear and contact marks.

Our Visual Snapshot and the section on The Complex Art of Grading Ancient Roman Coins offer more detail on this.

Q6. Where should I store my ancient coin collection?

You should store your coins in a cool, dry place with stable temperature and humidity. Always use archival-safe, PVC-free holders. Avoid basements, attics, or any area with high humidity or temperature fluctuations. Individual storage is best to prevent coins from touching and scratching each other.

Q7. Do test cuts or countermarks decrease a coin's value?

Not necessarily. While they do alter the coin, these marks can be a fascinating part of its history. A test cut or a countermark tells a unique story about the coin's journey and can often increase its desirability to a collector who appreciates these historical nuances.

Q8. What are the most common metals for Roman coins?

The most common metals are gold (aureus), silver (denarius), and bronze/copper alloys (sestertius, dupondius, as, and follis). Each metal has its own characteristics and preservation challenges, with bronze being the most susceptible to environmental damage.

Final Thoughts

My journey into collecting ancient Roman coins has been filled with both exhilarating highs and frustrating lows. I’ve held coins that felt like they were still warm from the mint and others that were a constant reminder of my own ignorance. But through it all, the single most important lesson I’ve learned is that this isn’t just a hobby of acquisition. It’s a hobby of stewardship. You’re not just buying a coin; you’re buying a piece of history that has survived against all odds. Your job is to understand it, appreciate its unique story, and preserve it for the future. Don’t get hung up on a number on a label. Instead, focus on the coin itself—the quality of the strike, the beauty of the patina, and the history it holds. Find a coin that speaks to you, treat it with respect, and you will build a collection that is not just valuable, but truly meaningful. Ready to start your own incredible journey? Begin with research, a trusted dealer, and a willingness to be humbled by history.

Keywords: ancient Roman coins, grading, preservation, numismatics, coin collecting

🔗 The 7-Minute Guide to Edwardian Era Posted Aug 31, 2025